Andre Onana and Ederson Moraes are among the best modern goalkeepers in the world at present. Following the departure of David de Gea, Manchester United is set to sign Onana as their new goalkeeper.
Onana has gained significant hype after his impressive performance in the UEFA Champions League final, placing him alongside top-tier goalkeepers like Ederson of Manchester City and Alisson of Liverpool.
In this article, we will compare the stats of Onana and Ederson to assess their respective abilities.
2022/2023 Season Comparison
Let’s examine the performance of both goalkeepers during the 2022/2023 season and compare their stats.
Onana vs Ederson Stats
Andre Onana and Ederson Moraes Stats Comparison Breakdown
Based on the stats from the picture above:
- Onana has a defensive action rate of 9.9%, which means he successfully intervenes or prevents the opposing team from scoring around 10% of the time. Ederson, on the other hand, has a higher defensive action rate of 39.5%, indicating that he is more involved in defensive plays.
- Onana contests aerial balls around 20.4% of the time, meaning he actively challenges for high balls during matches. Ederson contests aerial balls around 18.8% of the time, so he is slightly less involved in these situations.
- Onana has an exit line rate of 31.3%, which suggests that he comes off his goal line or ventures out of his penalty area to clear the ball or start an attack about 31.3% of the time. Ederson, in contrast, has a lower exit line rate of 8.9%, meaning he stays closer to his goal more often.
- Onana completes 94.1% of his passes, indicating that he has a high accuracy rate when distributing the ball. Ederson, while still good, has a slightly lower passing accuracy of 84.2%.
- Onana completes long passes around 67.8% of the time, suggesting he is effective at launching accurate long balls to his teammates. Ederson, however, has a lower success rate of 28.0% when attempting long passes.
- Onana completes short passes around 75.7% of the time, indicating he is proficient at playing short, accurate passes within his team. Ederson has a slightly lower success rate of 48.4% when it comes to short passes.
- Onana has a PSxG-GA of 79.6%, which measures the difference between the expected goals (PSxG) the opposing team should have scored against him and the actual goals conceded (GA). A higher value suggests that he prevents more goals than expected. Ederson, on the other hand, has a PSxG of 31.6%, indicating that he has prevented fewer goals than expected based on the quality of chances faced.
Who is Better in the 2022/2023 Season? Onana or Ederson?
Based on the recent season stats presented in this article, it can be concluded that Onana is a better goalkeeper than Ederson.
Onana demonstrates superior qualities as a modern goalkeeper, particularly in terms of his offensive communication with other players on the pitch, as evidenced by his higher accuracy in passing.
He is good at making defensive actions, challenging for high balls, coming off his goal line, and passing the ball accurately. He also performs well in preventing goals beyond what is expected.
Ederson also excels in most areas but has a lower defensive action rate overall. He has a lower rate of preventing goals compared to the expected number based on the quality of scoring opportunities encountered.
He also contests fewer aerial balls, stays closer to his goal line, and has a slightly lower passing accuracy.
